Green  and rusted dumpster is piled with overflowing garbage bags with blurred industrial background

3 Pretend Customer Experience Strategies That Belong in the Dumpster

6 minute read
Jeannie Walters avatar
Don't fall for make-believe strategies that don't require dedicated resources of time and people.

Customer experience doesn’t need your attention.

If you have customers, they are having an experience. That experience, the sum of all those touchpoints, builds their perception of your brand based on their expectations. 

But customer experience strategy demands your attention. CX strategy is where the vision and promises made to customers are met with strategic planning, effective measurement and a true understanding of what success means.

Who Gets the Job of CX Strategist?

I hear from leaders who are asked to “lead CX” with little more than a new place on the org chart and a pat on the back. They aren’t asked to define the strategy. They aren’t asked to define success. And they certainly don’t have a universal definition of success to measure.

There is little discussion except for maybe an explanation of how important it is, or how it’s been neglected too long. Organizational comparisons are made: our organization versus Zappos or Ritz-Carlton or maybe the local Starbucks barista who “always knows customer orders!”

So this poor soul — the man or woman who has done such a good job that their reward is more responsibility and an exciting challenge — is asked to create a customer experience strategy out of thin air.

Related Article: Drive Growth by Improving Your Customer Experience Strategy

Determining What CX Strategy Really Is

But these are doers we’re talking about.

These are people who make things happen. So they jump in and get to work. They do their research, read the blogs, and the books, and even attend some webinars. They begin to see this customer experience thing as more than what they originally thought it was. And they learn there are professional organizations and those of us who have been discussing these topics for decades.

Strategy is no small thing, though. Strategy means designing a proactive structure to achieve positive outcomes. It means planning not only the work of one person, but how different leaders and departments will work together to achieve those big goals around customer experience. Speaking of goals — what should our goals be again?

Related Article: 8 Tips to Build a Winning Customer Experience Strategy 

Don’t Fall for Make-Believe CX Strategies

Sometimes that means creating something not only out of thin air, but a strategy with little or no dedicated resources of either time or people. And so they are left with few choices, but these exciting-to-discuss-but-difficult-to-deliver CX Strategies leave a lot to be desired. And I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but these well-meaning strategies aren’t strategies at all and simply won’t work.

These are a few of the “strategies” I see that are easy to fall for:

1. CX Strategy by Technology

The answer can look so promising. We’ll get a new solution! These tools have all the bells and whistles of the latest Tesla. We’ll be able to view our data from 300 different angles and ask customers for feedback at every turn!

Yes, tools can be a huge help. But technology on its own is never a solution. It’s a tool.

Without a clear understanding of not just what’s needed to set up a new technology, but how to also make it evolve with your organizational needs, technology can turn into a very expensive and time-consuming distraction. Your customers won’t care if you view their feedback from dozens of angles if they are just trying to tell you something is not working for them and nobody seems to care.

2. CX Strategy by Journey Mapping

Blasphemy! Journey mapping is the answer! I’m a big believer in mapping the experience. But sometimes this is the one tangible tool that people know of to understand customers.

Learning Opportunities

Produce a beautiful map and get everyone in the company to appreciate it by going on a roadshow with it.

Customer journey mapping is not the problem. Mapping is another tool. It should be a living, evolving way to understand your customer’s journey both today and in the future.

The process of mapping and cross-functional teamwork should result in participants internalizing how they fit in the overall experience and how mapping can help. It’s not about a perfect deliverable. The map is only worth anything if it tells you where you are going. Customer Journey Mapping (CJM) often becomes a lesson in history instead of an impetus for changing the future.

Yes, mapping is very effective. No, it’s not a magic wand on its own. 

3. CX Strategy by Platitudes

This one is probably the most insidious.

It’s so easy to say the right thing around customer experience. We can all agree on what an ideal experience should be for customers. None of us set out to make our customers frustrated or irritated with our processes. Saying things like “omnichannel is important to customers now” or “we need to make our offline and online experiences work together” doesn’t do a lot of good if the resources and communication aren’t there to back those up.

I watched a CEO hold a companywide “town hall” a few years ago with hundreds of employees in front of him and thousands more watching globally via video links. The big meeting was about “working smarter, not harder, for our customers.”

There were no guidelines or tools to help employees do this. But don’t worry, there were handouts! The handouts said things like “Is there a smarter way to do this?” and “Customers want more, so we need to deliver more for them.” Most employees applauded at the end and then walked away and got back to work in exactly the same way as before the meeting.

Customer Experience — Not Just the Latest Tool or Catchword

Customer experience strategy is not about one program or tool or catchy phrase.

It’s about building a foundation for an entire organization to see things from the customer’s perspective. It is SO much easier said than done, especially in light of deadlines and shifting priorities and office politics.

Before taking on a generic customer experience strategy, take a moment to think about what your goals really are. Until then, don’t forget customers are the reason we’re here. (Feel free to print that on a poster!)

So what can you do to lead your CX strategy? We’ll cover that next time!

About the author

Jeannie Walters

Jeannie Walters is an award-winning customer experience expert, international keynote speaker, and Founder of Experience Investigators: A firm that’s pioneered helping companies increase sales and customer retention through elevated customer experiences.

About CMSWire

For nearly two decades CMSWire, produced by Simpler Media Group, has been the world's leading community of customer experience professionals.


Today the CMSWire community consists of over 5 million influential customer experience, digital experience and customer service leaders, the majority of whom are based in North America and employed by medium to large organizations. Our sister community, Reworked gathers the world's leading employee experience and digital workplace professionals.

Join the Community

Get the CMSWire Mobile App

Download App Store
Download google play